The paper released at the event organized by the Institute for Comparative Studies in Social Sciences and Law (Inecip) which took place at the Faculty of Law, National University of Cordoba, collects, analyzes and concludes about instances of judicial and police violence that occurred from 2008 to 2010.
The authors of the paper, and Derna Peano Alejandra Montero, considered that "in recent years, the word (in) security, feelings of insecurity or specifics of increased crime rates have affected the public agenda and policies adopted to address the problem. "
In the summary of his investigative work, and Peano Montero added that "the Doctrine of Tolerance Zero had a major impact in the province of Cordoba, where the foundations of the doctrine are displayed on the agreement reached in 2004 between Gov. John Manuel de la Sota, the "Axel Blumberg Foundation" and "Manhattan Institute for Policy Research United States." The agreement entailed cutting measures and selective enforcement of a particular social group. "
"Thus, we added more security officers in the police force while increased arrests for minor offenses," they added in this regard.
"The Offences Code, Act 8431, is denounced by his unconstitutional and arbitrary character that allows the law to make arrests, also brandished in his approach.
"In this sense the discourse of insecurity occludes the networks of conflict, compared to the insecurity of access to education, employment and health The State responds with selective criminal policies, where the social group hardest hit are the young of popular sectors to which they are constructed as bearers of danger, "they said representatives from the group and then relate their genesis.
"So in September 2008, is constituted as a collective group Autoconvocados Neighborhood Against Police Abuse (VACAP), the main objective to denounce the abuses of authority by police forces, "remarked.
"In turn, the local newspaper (El Diario) also was established as a place for reporting, where different actors come forward to report and seek public protection against institutional violence by the repressive power," says Alejandra Derna and .
"Thus, it seems important to try to ask questions and describe the abuse of authority to which young people are exposed to popular sectors of the city of Villa Maria, the group rounded out the neighbor.
The bodies of punishment
"selective-enforcement policies by the state policy is one of the most visible and political power is exercised over bodies," the authors provide material submitted for consideration to those attending the Congress.
"In the city of Villa Maria, which has 88,643 inhabitants, were conducted in 2008, 2,725 arrests for violations and in 2009, 2,362 arrests were made, where the articles that presented more arrests is the figure of loitering, scandal on the public highway and refusal or failure to identify " revered.
"While considering the report by Coria, A. and Etchechurry, H. (2010) in the province of Cordoba, the police made 54,223 arrests, where nearly half (49%) affected younger than 25 years. The arrests by age are distributed approximately as follows: 44% are aged between 18 and 25, 20, 8% between 26 and 35, more than 45 years, 17.4% from 36 to 45, 8, 7% and under 18, 5.2%.
"The data account for the age of the population that the State selectively punish, but which overlaps with social and economic conditions. The young people accompanying VACAP organization for both complaints against police violence, arbitrary arrests come as the neighborhoods Roque Sáenz Peña, Las Acacias, General Roca, San Nicolás, Los Olmos, San Martín, Nicolás Avellaneda, Philip Botta, San Juan Bautista , San Justo, Carlos Pellegrini, Beaches, Central and the towns of Villa Nueva, The Partridge and Ballesteros ", highlight the text of the paper.
"In this sense, taking into account the data provided by the 'Centro Regional Statistics of the Municipality of Villa Maria' (Cermvm) based on 2001 census data, neighborhoods Carlos Pellegrini, Philippe Botta, Nicholas Avellaneda and Los Olmos households have more than 40% of Basic Needs (UBN). In turn, the neighborhoods of Acacias, Sáenz Peña, General Roca, San Martin, San Nicolas, and Las Playas, households have less than 40% of NBI, "they said.
"In turn, most young people are men, but violence is also applied to the female, where a 13 year old girl was shot by police, while another girl was severely beaten in a foot causing immobility had operated it. The physical and symbolic violence exerted on the body, individual, subjective and social has its complicity in the power, both medical knowledge and health care is of the police and health professionals who deal with persons violated by the police, do not report correctly injury. This complicity is also given in the knowledge of Justice, distant and strange in their own language and, where families spend hours walking around without answers or prosecution without give effect to its claims ", is bounded in the next line.
"On the other hand, is relevant to note that the arrests occur recurrently way to work, where young men are engaged in construction work as masons, blacksmiths, placement air conditioners or supermarkets.
In this sense, the complaints brought in the newspaper as complaints Unveils VACAP organization, whose victims Criminal State-poor youth, neighborhoods and predominantly male, "say the authors .
"Thus, there is a negative construction with respect to the condition of being young, popular sectors that marks them as potential 'suspects'. In this sense, "selection victimizing signs do not mean the difference but the in-difference that introduces disorder into the system. Thus, contrary to what is repeated from the idea of \u200b\u200bdiscrimination: the difference is never what haunts the pursuers, but his ineffable contrary, the in-deferenciación. Not that I see another law just or the other, but the anomaly, we see no other rule but it's abnormal. "(Boito and Levstein, 2005:14)
" Arbitrary arrests not only restrict the ability to move freely the city, but also some young people choose to move to another city, "said Montero and Peano. Outline
conclusion
"This work, intended as a contribution to a debate to be the company with respect to the security-insecurity problem in this regard we some open questions regarding what we consider for security, "remarked the members of the VACAP.
"The increase in recent years both patrolling the city, as police have told us not low crime rates but are becoming more prevalent cases of police violence and arbitrary mass arrests to justify the 'effectiveness of the police,' "they said.
In this sense, Emilio Sevesso says "while this practice has tended to naturalize in the forms of policing, socially have become increasingly accepted and tolerated under the re-production of an extended imaginary game called insecurity.
First, the sensitivity construction built around a permanent personal and collective risk (always fear, fear everywhere) which is co-constituted - as we know - by incidence of the media, play politics and urban myths.
Secondly, the creation of a ghost that is imposed as an embodiment of the fears (of poverty, youth) and a fantasy as a channel that complements it conveys a plausible solution (the public security policy and its complement private) . This will produce the feeling that you are fighting and insecurity that makes it far fair ", summarizes Sevesso. Using
foot in the previous statement, the ideologues of the document say: "Thus, the State punishes young selectively popular sectors, restricting their options for action, not only to move freely around the city, but also lose their jobs. In this sense, give a strong battle deconstructing the meanings that are given to the condition of youth anchored in poverty who are credited by both the state and socially legitimate bearers of danger. "
"While democratic laws that are necessary to allow control of the civil society response punitive institutions. It is important to the struggle that has been gestating antirepresivas organizations at the national and provincial levels, as it is a hopeful sign of naturalization of non-violence. As well, the daily struggle that made the parents of young violated by the police before the corruption of power, "they concluded.
Source: http://www.eldiariocba.com.ar/noticias/nota.asp?nid=37769